Contact us Heritage collections Image license terms
HOME ACL ACD C&A INF CCD Mainframes Super-computers Graphics Networking Bryant Archive Data Literature
Further reading □ Overview □ 1985 □ December,Paris □ 1986 □ February,ParisMay,ParisJuly,ParisSeptember,ParisDecember,Brussels □ 1987 □ February,ParisApril,ParisMay,NiceJuly,GenevaSeptember,ParisOctober,GenevaNovember,Paris □ 1988 □ February,DublinMarch,ParisApril,IzmirMay,ParisJune,ParisJuly,ParisAugust,ParisSeptember,ParisOctober,Tel-AvivDecember,Paris □ 1989 □ February,ParisApril,AmsterdamMay/June,HeraklionJuly,ParisSeptember,AmsterdamOctober,LisbonDecember,Paris □ 1990 □ February,AmsterdamApril,ParisMay,KillarneyJune,AmsterdamSeptember,ParisNovember,CairoDecember,Amsterdam
CISD Archives Contact us Heritage archives Image license terms

Search

   
CCDPaul Bryant's ArchiveEARN Executive Committee
CCDPaul Bryant's ArchiveEARN Executive Committee
ACL ACD C&A INF CCD CISD Archives
Further reading

Overview
1985
December,Paris
1986
February,ParisMay,ParisJuly,ParisSeptember,ParisDecember,Brussels
1987
February,ParisApril,ParisMay,NiceJuly,GenevaSeptember,ParisOctober,GenevaNovember,Paris
1988
February,DublinMarch,ParisApril,IzmirMay,ParisJune,ParisJuly,ParisAugust,ParisSeptember,ParisOctober,Tel-AvivDecember,Paris
1989
February,ParisApril,AmsterdamMay/June,HeraklionJuly,ParisSeptember,AmsterdamOctober,LisbonDecember,Paris
1990
February,AmsterdamApril,ParisMay,KillarneyJune,AmsterdamSeptember,ParisNovember,CairoDecember,Amsterdam

Minutes of EARN Executive Committee Meeting, 18,21 October 1989, Lisbon

EARN EXECUTIVE: 
Paul Bryant,         (PB)         Secretary
Avi Cohen,           (AC)
Frode Greisen,       (FG)         President
Michael Hebgen,      (MH)         Vice President
Jean-Claude Ippolito,(JCI)        Treasurer
Dennis Jennings,     (DJ)
Stephano Trumpy,     (ST)
EARN STAFF:     
Alain Auroux,        (AA)         Paris Office
Jerry Striplin(part) (JS)         EARN OSI Centre

Information of a contractual or personal nature which could prejudice EARN negotiations is not in the published EARN Executive minutes

29.1 Action review - EXEC127 89

Executive meeting 22
DJ - write to Physics Library
                                                                                  Retain
Board Meeting October 24/25, 1988
FG Circulate BITNET charter for Associate Networks                                Retain
Executive meeting 26
26.4      Update EARN technical and management plan EXEC25 89                     Retain
26.8      Revise and clarify EXEC59 89                                            Retain
26.9      Set up political and technical meetings with IBM in ESINET              Complete
26.13     Manage LISTSERV, provide detailed proposal LISTGATE                     Retain
26.14     Investigate statistics collection on a VAX                              Completed
Resolved - to review the collection of statistics on a VAX                        Action AA
Board meeting June 1/2, 1989
21.7.3    produce "server compensation" proposals                                 Completed
21.7.4    Investigate options for trans-Atlantic back-up                          Retain
Noted - further discussions are taking place with DEC.
Executive meeting July 6/7, 1989
27.4      To revise the "migration resources" EXEC62 89 as required EXEC          Retain
27.5      Amend EARN/NORDUNET agreement - EXEC81 89 and negotiate for signature   Complete
27.13     Investigate security group                                              Retain
27.15     The NOG and IP groups will be asked to report on gateways               Complete
Resolved - a paper will be circulated to the Executive for comment                Action ST
27.16     Clarify technical details for Italian G-box                             Retain
27.17     Form "Scholar Committee"                                                Complete
27.18     Send "Associate Membership Form" to BOD                                 Retain
27.21     Put confidential papers in LISTSERV                                     Retain
27.22     Investigate tax on spares for EARN equipment                            Complete
27.24     Review the EARN projects and tasks                                      Remove
Resolved - a draft EARN project report will be produced with a view to 
producing one regularly                                                           Action PB
Executive meeting September 7/8, 1989
28.1      Ask EOC to study conformation with COSINE specifications                Retain
28.1      Review the Icelandic situation                                          Retain
28.2      Send an amended version of the letter to Klaus Ullman (EXEC114 89)      Complete
28.3      Prepare slightly amended version of the
          1990 budget as per EXEC102 89 for the BOD                               Complete
28.3      Send reminder to countries not having
          confirmed their 1990 contribution agreement                             Complete
28.3      Write to G-box sites with respect to maintenance. 
Information from DJ and JS                                                        Retain
28.4      Hopefully update first 3 pages of EXEC113 89
          with server compensation figures and submit to BOD                      Complete
28.8      Amend BOD agenda and issue                                              Complete
28.10     Re-draft EXEC109 89, issue to Executive for
          electronic comment and submit to BOD                                    Complete
28.11     Re-draft EXEC110 89, issue to Executive for
          electronic comment and submit to BOD                                    Complete
28.12     Send letter to Eric Thomas regarding LISTSERV 1.6                       Complete
28.16     Issue invoice to UK for full balance of contribution                    Remove
28.16     Prepare proposal on sanctions on the UK in
          the event of non-payment to submit to BOD                               Remove
28.18     Issue amended OSI development plan to the BOD by September 14, 1989     Complete
28.19     Investigate Belgium situation with respect
          to their international connection                                       Complete
Noted - the Paris to Belgium link has been removed and the EARN traffic now uses 
the Leuven to Montpellier ESINET link.
28.20     Ask EARN France to comment on EXEC121 89                                Complete
Noted - EARN France will fund the first phase of the project for a PC mail server 
and EARN may be approached for support in 3 to 6 months.

Items for decision.

29.2 Verbal report on the OSI project was given by Jerry Striplin

Resolved - technical specification of DECNET in NORDUnet as it effects EARN is required Action JS

Resolved - technical specification of NJE/OSI will be published. Action DJ

Noted - the discussions with DEC on a TAL connection

Noted - successful testing of VAXVMS to IBM NJE/OSI and that a number of bugs have been detected.

29.3 Preparation for the Board of Directors meeting

29.3.1 EARN manager

Resolved - the financial requirements and implications of increasing the budget for an EARN manager will be presented to the Board of Directors.

Resolved - in response to a NOG request the NOG should be allowed to invite observers from BITNET and other networks through their chairman as well as observers from EARN countries not yet connected. No finance would be provided for such observers.

Resolved - the NOG LISTSERV directive was approved for presentation to the Board of Directors.

Resolved - the SNA group should be asked to bring forward a detailed plan based on section 6 of BOD44 89. Action MH

Resolved - the Executive will investigate the political aspects of operating SNA on a wider scale. Action DJ

29.4 Server compensation - EXEC129 89

Noted - EXEC129 89 has been withdrawn in the light of discussion in the NOG and will not be published. A new proposal will be presented for the next Executive meeting. Action MH

29.5 EARN-IXI meeting - EXEC128 89, EXEC131 89

Noted - EXEC128 89 which will be published and EXEC131 89 which is confidential.

29.6 Post mortem of Board of Directors meeting

Resolved - in response to EXEC137 89 (mission and strategy) members will produce their own views which will be discussed electronically and FG will produce a draft document. Action all, FG

29.7 Temporary connection DK-SE and FI-SE - EXEC139 89

Resolved - the proposed connections were approved subject to the EOC confirming that there are no problems with respect to their access to the relevant G-boxes (DJ) and that the NOG confirms that they have no objections (AA). Action DJ, AA

Resolved - to set up a working group to investigate NJE over DECNET Action FG

29.8 Request for a virtual SNA circuit between CERN and CUNY

Resolved - to re-consider the request when the final report and recommendations of the SNA working group are known.

29.9 Proposal for country's connection through PPSDN - EXEC132 89

Resolved - the proposal was agreed in principal. Each request will be dealt with by the EARN manager who must be convinced by the NOG that the plan is viable.

29.10 Use of Board of Directors distribution list.

Resolved - to include new country or new co-operating country directors and deputies on acceptance in the Board of Directors' distribution list. They will also be invited to meetings of the Board of Directors.

29.11 IXI questionnaire - EXEC135 89

Resolved - the form will be filled in for the EOC NT to IXI connection by N O'Reilly and PB. Action DJ

Resolved - a copy of the form will be sent to each director asking for volunteers to test and evaluate IXI connections with E or G box connections. The list of participants will be selected from the replies. DJ and PB to check the letter. Action FG

Resolved - the details of the project to test and evaluate the connections will be developed from the "OSI development Plan" document. Action DJ

29.12 EARN agreements

Resolved - all signed EARN agreements will be circulated to the Board of directors with their papers.

Confidential items for decision

29.13 New entries in the EARN tables

Resolved - no action will be taken over certain EARN table entries.

Executive planning

29.14 Agenda for meeting 30, December 13, 1989 at 11.00 and on December 14, 1989 finishing at 15.00 at CIRCE, Paris.

The EARN office opening will be December 13 at 18.00. French journalists and sponsors will be invited.

The important topics will be:-

Draft 1991 budget and country contributions including server compensation.
Further planning for OSI - DJ.
EARN strategy - FG. 
Security group - AC.
SNA final document - MH. 

Items for information

29.15 EARN NORDUnet agreement - EXEC130 89 and update EXEC136 89

29.16 Terminal and mail conversions - EXEC133 89

29.17 Donations and grants - EXEC134 89

29.18 Mission and strategy - EXEC137 89

29.19 Call for expression of interest for consultancy and management for OSI network - EXEC138 89.

Noted - the president has registered EARNs interest.

Action List

Executive meeting 22
DJ - write to Physics Library
Board Meeting October 24/25, 1988
FG Circulate BITNET charter for Associate Networks
Executive meeting 26
26.4      Update EARN technical and management plan
          EXEC25 89                                    AA
26.8      Revise and clarify EXEC59 89                 AA
26.13     Manage LISTSERV, provide detailed proposal
          LISTGATE                                     AA
Board meeting June 1/2, 1989
21.7.4    Investigate options for trans-Atlantic back-up DJ,FG
Executive meeting July 6/7, 1989
27.4      To revise the "migration resources" EXEC62
          89 as required EXEC                          DJ
27.13     Investigate security group                   AA MH
27.16     Clarify technical details for Italian G-box  ST
27.18     Send "Associate Membership Form" to BOD      AA
27.21     Put confidential papers in LISTSERV          PB
Executive meeting September 7/8, 1989
28.1      Ask EOC to study conformation with COSINE
          specifications                               DJ
28.1      Review the Icelandic situation               FG
28.3      Write to G-box sites with respect to
          maintenance. Information from DJ and JS      AA
Board meeting October 19/20, 1989
22.5.3    To develop a long term strategy
22.9.3    To further consider actions in the case of 
          the late payment of contributions
22.9.4    To provide proposals for the connection of 
          countries by alternative means, e.g. ISDN
 
Executive meeting October 18 and 21, 1989
29.1      Review the collection of statistics on a VAX AA
29.1      Circulate NOG and IP gateway document to the
          Executive                                    ST
29.1      Produce draft EARN project report            PB
29.2      Produce technical specification of DECNET in 
          Nordunet as it effects EARN                  JS
29.2      Publish technical specification of NJE/OSI   DJ
29.3.1    Ask SNA group to provide a detailed plan 
          based on section 6 of BOD44 89               MH
29.3.1    Investigate political use of SNA on a wider
          scale                                        DJ
29.4      Produce server compensation proposal         MH
29.6      Produce long term strategy document          All
29.7      Confirm that the DK G-box will be accessible
          from the EOC and confirm the NOG have no
          objections to EXEC139 89                     DJ, AA
29.7      Set up a working group to study NJE over
          DECNET                                       FG
29.8      Re-consider CERN to CUNY circuit in the light
          of the SNA final report                      Exec
29.11     Ask N O'Reilly and PB to fill in IXI form    DJ
29.11     Copy IXI form to all BOD members and ask for
          volunteers to test IXI.                      FG
29.11     Develop OSI development plan for IXI test    DJ
⇑ Top of page
© Chilton Computing and UKRI Science and Technology Facilities Council webmaster@chilton-computing.org.uk
Our thanks to UKRI Science and Technology Facilities Council for hosting this site